Imagine a health condition that leads to the death of up to one-quarter of those hospitalized with it.
It’s a condition that can convert a independent older person into one stuck in hospital awaiting a bed in a long-term care home. A condition that affects up to 25 per cent of older persons presenting to hospital, and is acquired by a further 25 per cent while in hospital. A condition that prolongs hospital stays, ties up beds and backs up emergency rooms.
The costs of this condition exceeded $160 billion in the United States alone in 2011. Finally, consider how this condition occurs in almost every hospital around the world, essentially making it a pandemic.
No, this is not COVID-19, monkeypox or influenza.
This is delirium. A condition we’ve known about for decades. A condition that often goes unrecognized. A condition often caused by hospital practices. A condition that we can prevent, but usually don’t.
Delirium in hospitals
Delirium usually occurs during an acute illness and causes a rapid decline in cognition. Older persons, particularly those with pre-existing changes in cognition, are at risk.
Delirium is often triggered in hospital by enforced bed rest, misplaced or lost hearing and visual aids, sleep disruption from noisy and brightly lit wards at night, over-prescription of unnecessary and often sedating medications or overuse of “tethers” like bladder tubes or intravenous lines.
People with delirium can experience disorientation, agitation or paranoia, and may become a risk to themselves or to others. As a result, many are restrained physically or chemically with drugs such as antipsychotics, which can cause injury, reduced mobility or death.
Delirium often leaves patients too disabled or confused to return home. Some eventually do so after a period of rehabilitation, but many others never fully regain their independence and are placed on wait lists for long-term care homes. Adding insult to injury, because these patients are stable enough to not require acute hospital care, they are designated “alternate level of care (ALC)” and are charged a daily co-payment.
An emerging and dangerous infectious disease, a drug with unacceptable side-effects or a faulty medical device would trigger a major public outcry and prompt regulatory action. Yet, something as widespread and harmful as delirium — an injury clearly linked to hospital practices — rarely comes to attention.
Instead, we focus on its downstream complications: high ALC rates, hospital overcrowding and emergency room backlogs. In what amounts to systemic gas-lighting, blame is directed at those elderly “bed-blockers” and pressure builds on governments to act. Pundits and politicians debate the merits of private health care but ultimately, the same solution — one that does nothing to make hospitals safer for older persons — is reapplied: more long-term care.
Enabling better aging: The 4 things seniors need, and the 4 things that need to change
More long-term care homes are then built, into which ALC patients are “decanted” (a system planning term). ALC rates come down, challenges with “access and flow” (another system planning term) are reduced and hospital pressures eased. The issue goes away — at least, until the long-term care homes become full again and the entire cycle is repeated, like a bad sequel to the movie Groundhog Day.
Preventing delirium and its downstream effects
Delirium can be prevented. The Hospital Elder Life Program (HELP) was developed in the 1990s and has been shown to substantially reduce the odds of hospital-acquired delirium by over 50 per cent, reduce in-hospital falls by 42 per cent, prevent hospital-acquired disability, and reduce costs, both in-hospital and by avoiding long-term care.
Characterized as a “low-tech and high-touch” intervention and supported by specialized staff and volunteers, HELP identifies older adults at risk of delirium upon hospital admission and immediately implements an array of senior-friendly measures.
These measures include regular exercise; elimination of unnecessary tethers; cognitive stimulation; attention to vision, hearing and hydration needs; and sleep protocols such as noise reduction (no more jarring “CODE BLUE!” blasting over the intercom at 3 a.m.), back rubs, relaxation tapes and music, and herbal tea or warm milk. It’s low-tech. And it works.
Yet, over two decades after the publication of a landmark clinical trial, and despite ample supporting evidence, the implementation of HELP remains the exception, rather than the rule. Hospitals in Canada are simply not mandated to provide senior-friendly care. It is time they were.
Hospitals must also be required to measure and publicly report on rates of hospital-acquired delirium and functional decline. This type of mandatory, standardized and publicly available information collection is how long-term care homes in Canada were able to compare their performance, learn from one another and reduce unnecessary antipsychotic use.
Rather than remaining stuck in this Groundhog Day scenario, it is only through structured and mandatory senior-friendly quality improvement that our health-care system will eventually escape an ALC loop that ultimately affects us all.
George A Heckman is affiliated with interRAI, a not-for-profit scientific organization that develops assessment systems for vulnerable populations in various health care sectors. He would like to acknowledge Dr. Amy Miles and Ms. Michelle Klosch who provided feedback on earlier drafts of this article.