• Home
  • Health & Wellness
  • Disclaimer
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • DMCA Notice
  • Home
  • Health & Wellness
  • Disclaimer
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • DMCA Notice
24/7 Health News
No Result
View All Result
Home Article

Martha’s rule: second-opinion law can work – but only if organisational shortcomings are addressed

September 7, 2023
in Article
Martha’s rule: second-opinion law can work – but only if organisational shortcomings are addressed
Martha’s Rule would empower patients and their families to call for treatment reviews and formal second opinions. gpointstudio/ Shutterstock

As things stand, hospital patients in England have no legal right to a second medical opinion. But that could soon change, as a campaign to give patients formal entitlement to an urgent second opinion is gathering momentum and gaining support from key figures, including those in government as well as the NHS England Ombudsman. The proposal, called Martha’s rule, is named after a young girl whose life might have been saved by it.

In 2021, 13-year-old Martha Mills died following an injury she sustained while on holiday with her family. Martha was treated at King’s College Hospital in London, where she developed life-threatening sepsis. The inquest following Martha’s death found it was avoidable, and that she would have survived were it not for tragic failures in the medical care she received. These failures included doctors withholding important information about Martha’s condition from her parents and ignoring their concerns.

The proposal, championed by Martha’s mother, Merope Mills, seeks to improve patient safety in hospitals and prevent avoidable deaths like Martha’s by empowering patients and their families to call for treatment reviews and formal second opinions.

Guidance from the General Medical Council (the regulatory body for doctors in England) mentions that in some circumstances – typically when a patient doesn’t agree with a doctor’s decision or opinion – it may be appropriate for doctors to discuss the option of a second opinion. But though patients have a right to ask for a second opinion, there’s no legal requirement for doctors to provide one.

Martha’s rule would give patients and families the right to seek a rapid review by a separate clinical team – or a second opinion from another specialist doctor based in the same hospital but independent of the team around the patient.

Second opinion

There are several similar systems in place around the world. Many of these were introduced following cases like Martha’s.

For example, in Queensland, Australia, Ryan’s rule (named after Ryan Saunders, who died in 2007) gives patients and families the right to escalate concerns beyond the hospital and request a clinical review of the patient’s case. As of 2022, Ryan’s rule had been deployed 7,300 times since it was introduced in 2013. The process has led to clearer communication about care between patients, their families and doctors.

Two intensive care nurses attend to a sick female patient.
Similar policies in other parts of the world have benefited patients.
Peakstock/ Shutterstock

Family-initiated rapid response teams also operate in many US hospitals. When used by a family member, this process provides patients with immediate bedside care from a specialist team. There’s some indication rapid response teams can lead to improved outcomes for patients, including fewer deaths. In one medical centre where this system was introduced, it resulted in markedly fewer cardiac arrests and fewer fatalities from these.

Numerous NHS trusts in England have also introduced “Call 4 Concern” (C4C) – a system which enables patients and families who feel their concerns are not being addressed to escalate the issue to a “critical care outreach team”.

A 2019 review of how the system was operating in the Royal Berkshire Trust (where the model was pioneered) found the service had been used 534 times in seven years – and that 95% of the calls placed were using the service appropriately. In a fifth of cases, significant interventions were required. As the service became established, some staff used it too. There have since been calls to implement the system in all NHS trusts.

It’s clear that such systems can work to improve care for patients. But they are not always straightforward to implement. Some people may lack the confidence to challenge healthcare staff or may not feel they should second-guess a doctor’s opinion, which may inhibit their ability to ask for help. There may be organisational barriers to putting effective systems in place – such as staffing levels and budgetary constraints. There have also been concerns about the potential for inappropriate use or overuse of the facility to request a rapid response (though, as the Royal Berkshire review found, this was minimal).

Over the past decade, there have been considerable changes within the NHS to give greater power and voice to patients and their families. For instance, in 2013 the NHS Constitution was published, which brought patient rights to the fore. In 2015, the landmark case of Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board raised the standard that doctors must meet when informing patients about the risks of proposed medical procedures, and about reasonable alternatives.

In 2014, a statutory duty of candour was introduced in England. This includes a legal obligation on health professionals to inform patients and families when something goes wrong, and to apologise.

Advocates for Martha’s rule say it would further “re-balance the power between patients and medics”, and this would undoubtedly be welcome. While the proposal is a necessary step, however, other problems within the NHS – including staff shortages and underfunding – could undermine its impact.

The Conversation

Mary Neal does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ShareTweetSharePin
Next Post
The orgasm gap and why women climax less than men

When IVF fails it can be devastating – so why do clinics offer so little in the way of support?

Most Read

What causes stuttering? A speech pathology researcher explains the science and the misconceptions around this speech disorder

What causes stuttering? A speech pathology researcher explains the science and the misconceptions around this speech disorder

December 15, 2022
morning back pain

Morning Again Ache Trigger Is Not the Mattress

October 11, 2021

Why Circadian Rhythms Matter for Your Health

July 30, 2024
lower back pain relief exercises

5 decrease again ache aid workouts

October 11, 2021

4 steps to building a healthier relationship with your phone

January 28, 2025
3 years after legalization, we have shockingly little information about how it changed cannabis use and health harms

3 years after legalization, we have shockingly little information about how it changed cannabis use and health harms

October 15, 2021
Nasal vaccines promise to stop the COVID-19 virus before it gets to the lungs – an immunologist explains how they work

Nasal vaccines promise to stop the COVID-19 virus before it gets to the lungs – an immunologist explains how they work

December 14, 2022
bleeding in gum

When The Bleeding in gum Is Severe ?

October 11, 2021
Good Night Sleep

6 Causes of Good Evening Sleep

October 11, 2021
Kick up your heels – ballroom dancing offers benefits to the aging brain and could help stave off dementia

Kick up your heels – ballroom dancing offers benefits to the aging brain and could help stave off dementia

January 3, 2023
Biden is getting prostate cancer treatment, but that’s not the best choice for all men − a cancer researcher describes how she helped her father decide

Biden is getting prostate cancer treatment, but that’s not the best choice for all men − a cancer researcher describes how she helped her father decide

May 20, 2025
Ten small changes you can make today to prevent weight gain

Ten small changes you can make today to prevent weight gain

October 12, 2021

COVID vaccines: how one can pace up rollout in poorer international locations

October 5, 2021

This Simple Hygiene Habit Could Cut Your Risk of Stroke, New Research Reveals

February 1, 2025

Multiple sclerosis: the link with earlier infection just got stronger – new study

October 12, 2021
Support and collaboration with health-care providers can help people make health decisions

Support and collaboration with health-care providers can help people make health decisions

December 16, 2021
Greece to make COVID vaccines mandatory for over-60s, but do vaccine mandates work?

Greece to make COVID vaccines mandatory for over-60s, but do vaccine mandates work?

December 1, 2021
Five ways to avoid pain and injury when starting a new exercise regime

Five ways to avoid pain and injury when starting a new exercise regime

December 30, 2022
woman covered with white blanket

Exploring the Impact of Sleep Patterns on Mental Health

August 4, 2024

Maximize Your Performance – Sync with Your Circadian Rhythms

August 9, 2024
Why are some people faster than others? 2 exercise scientists explain the secrets of running speed

Why are some people faster than others? 2 exercise scientists explain the secrets of running speed

April 29, 2024
Backlash to transgender health care isn’t new − but the faulty science used to justify it has changed to meet the times

Backlash to transgender health care isn’t new − but the faulty science used to justify it has changed to meet the times

January 30, 2024
News of war can impact your mental health — here’s how to cope

Binge-eating disorder is more common than many realise, yet it’s rarely discussed – here’s what you need to know

December 2, 2022
As viral infections skyrocket, masks are still a tried-and-true way to help keep yourself and others safe

As viral infections skyrocket, masks are still a tried-and-true way to help keep yourself and others safe

December 14, 2022
GPs don’t give useful weight-loss advice – new study

GPs don’t give useful weight-loss advice – new study

December 16, 2022
Nutrition advice is rife with misinformation − a medical education specialist explains how to tell valid health information from pseudoscience

Nutrition advice is rife with misinformation − a medical education specialist explains how to tell valid health information from pseudoscience

January 28, 2025
FDA limits access to COVID-19 vaccine to older adults and other high-risk groups – a public health expert explains the new rules

FDA limits access to COVID-19 vaccine to older adults and other high-risk groups – a public health expert explains the new rules

May 21, 2025
Four ways to avoid gaining weight over the festive period – but also why you shouldn’t fret about it too much

Four ways to avoid gaining weight over the festive period – but also why you shouldn’t fret about it too much

December 22, 2022
Nurses’ attitudes toward COVID-19 vaccination for their children are highly influenced by partisanship, a new study finds

Nurses’ attitudes toward COVID-19 vaccination for their children are highly influenced by partisanship, a new study finds

December 2, 2022
How hot is too hot for the human body? Our lab found heat + humidity gets dangerous faster than many people realize

How hot is too hot for the human body? Our lab found heat + humidity gets dangerous faster than many people realize

July 6, 2022
  • Home
  • Health & Wellness
  • Disclaimer

© 2020 DAILY HEALTH NEWS

  • Home
  • Health & Wellness
  • Disclaimer
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • DMCA Notice

© 2020 DAILY HEALTH NEWS